The last two Colts head coaches (Caldwell 2009-11, Pagano 2012-17) each finished their tenures with winning records. Caldwell went 26-22 with a Super Bowl XLIV appearance while Pagano went 56-46 with three playoff trips and an AFC Championship Game loss in the infamous Deflategate game. However, both drew criticism for their conservative approach and poor in-game management.
QB Aaron Rodgers will make either of them look like an offensive genius!